Activity
Mon
Wed
Fri
Sun
Dec
Jan
Feb
Mar
Apr
May
Jun
Jul
Aug
Sep
Oct
Nov
What is this?
Less
More
23 contributions to Liberty Politics Discussion
Speculating about what may have been
In yesterday's discussion group, Sid told me I was comparing what happens to what might have been, and I didn't understand what he was referring to. I can't find him in the members. I think I understand now: I said I don't think there is any reason to think any Israeli PM other than Netanyahu would have acheived less during the current term with the horrors it seen. So it is possible that Sid was telling me about that that I am comparing what might have been (a different PM in the same period of past time) to what actually happened (Netanyahu). So if this is the case, I would like to remind you, Sid, that I was responding to you saying you can't imagine another PM acheiveing the same as Bibi did, which is the same thing: you were comparing Bibi to any possible alternative PM, which never existed. So I went on to say I don't believe such a comparison would yield any proof of Netanyahu being better. If you don't want me to do my comparison, you should probably pull your's back. One way or the other, we can always compare Netanyahu to actual past Israeli governments, as I suggested yesterday, and there again I can't find any proof of Netanyahu better than any of our past PMs. In the discussion yesterday I felt there was a lot of "I feel" and almost no actual arguments. I hope we are not being blind.
0 likes • Sep 28
@Siddhartha Naithani I literally just said I am not insisting anymore. What else do you want?
1 like • Sep 29
@Siddhartha Naithani Yah, I soon realized we probably both said all we had, so I deleted and wrote the one visible now. I don't need you to delete it, it's perfectly okay.
Cyrus the Great, as an adopting father to Jews, ChatGPT Image
Prompt: "An artistic historical allegory: Cyrus the Great portrayed as a benevolent adoptive father figure, symbolically embracing representatives of the ancient Jewish community, representing the protection and restoration associated with his policies toward the Jewish exiles. 6th-century BCE Persian and Jewish visual aesthetics, respectful, non-political."
Cyrus the Great, as an adopting father to Jews, ChatGPT Image
1 like • Sep 24
@Danial Mahdavi Thank you! these are great fathers indeed. I guess Pahlavi here means Reza Shah the first? I think from these 4 the one I know of the least is actually Zarathustra. I know about Kurosh from our Bible (we mispronounce his name as "Koresh", I blame the lack of vowels in Hebrew for that), listened to an audio book that sort of follows Ferdowsi's Shahnameh, and heard about each of the three amazing kings of the house of Pahlavi (whom I admire and hope to see back on the throne soon) from Armin and Goldie since the start of this horrible year. I guess I love three of your fathers, and would probably love the fourth one, or first one, have I known him well enough... I can wait for your victory. Javid Shah, Payandeh Iran.
1 like • Sep 28
@Danial Mahdavi Thank you. You have just explained to me something about my parents and the name they gave me: Yekhezkel. My mom used to explain to me that KH is the right way to translate the ח sound (closer to "Khayyām" than to "Chāi" or "Chat"). Now I know where it comes from. People used to ask me a lot why I write Yekhezkel and not Yechezkel, and my answer was that was how I was tought to write it.
Nick Matau found an AI for Islam.
https://www.deenbuddyai.com/ - this is the AI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iJMwCQyhSJ4 - here at ~3:25 it happens. That's what Durkas use to debate us.
Why alienate some Israelis?
At https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mnJrocWKVMA ~00:35 Armin says: "and with some miracle also by then Netanyahu has also won the October elections..." Now I know Armin wants Netanyahu to win and I accept that, even though I don't believe it is good for Israel or the Iranian people (not going into this now, I have no proof for this just like no one has proof for the opposite, doesn't matter). Still, such talk alienates about half of the Israelis in general, probably also specifically in the audience. I know I personaly feel like shit hearing this, because to me it sounds like "Israelis in general are neutral about Iran, lucky for us Iranians, one of the few pro-Iran Israelis, Netanyahu, is PM". So I guess this still makes sense because there are few Israelis in the world, and about half of them do support Netanyahu, and we aim for the hundreds of millions out there (and specifically in the US), so we don't really mean that much. I get it. And yes, we will support Iran one way or the other. Mostly because it's right, but also because even if this kind of talk makes us feel shit, our existential interest still conisides with Iran's. And I guess supporting and getting this shitty feeling is, after all, very familiar to us. May the Islamic dictatorship fall soon, and may the proud people of Iran have the freedom they deserve. Javid Shah, Payandeh Iran.
0
0
0 likes • Sep 25
@Daniel Dom Elica Le Bon sais that.
1-10 of 23
Ezekiel Hirshhorn
4
43 points to level up
@ezekiel-hirshhorn-8447
Israeli. Jew. Zionist. Iran in my heart, aching for freedom. Javid Shah.

Active 13d ago
Joined Jan 22, 2026
Powered by