Tomorrow we start our first philosophy class with Plato’s Apology, so here’s the quick background. Socrates lived in Athens from around 469–399 BCE. He never wrote a book. Almost everything we know about him comes from other people, especially Plato. Plato was much younger than Socrates and became one of his followers. Socrates’ execution seems to have had a huge effect on him, and many of Plato’s early dialogues preserve Socrates as the main character. That creates an important question whenever we read Plato. Are we hearing the historical Socrates, or Plato’s version of Socrates? We can’t always know. Before Socrates, many Greek philosophers were focused on questions about nature. - Thales: What is everything made of? - Heraclitus: Is everything constantly changing? - Parmenides:Can real being ever change? - Pythagoreans: What do number and harmony tell us about reality? Socrates turns the conversation much more directly toward human life: - What is justice? - What is courage? - What is virtue? - What makes someone good? - How do you know that you actually know what you claim to know? That last question is very important in the Apology. The oracle at Delphi supposedly declared that nobody was wiser than Socrates. Socrates found this confusing, so he went around questioning politicians, poets, craftsmen and other respected people. He discovered that many people were confident they knew things they couldn’t actually explain. His conclusion was essentially: “What I do not know, I do not think I know either.” — Apology 21d That is much closer to Socrates than the famous line “I know that I know nothing.” The historical setting matters too. Athens had recently lost the Peloponnesian War to Sparta, gone through political upheaval under the Thirty Tyrants, and only recently restored democracy. Socrates was already controversial. Aristophanes had mocked him in The Clouds, and some people associated him with dangerous intellectuals and politically notorious figures.