It is funny, but the walk into the bar setup is such an old cliche for a joke, and I have heard a lot of variations on the concept of physically walking into something. Of course, with a great delivery you can make it work, or for someone who hasn’t heard it. (You think he would have seen it). If you can double back on the joke, so that we can relate it in some third way, I think it would take us by surprise. The Norm MacDonald version might be “The blind guy says, “That’s okay. I wanted to do that. I’m a masochist.” (And then he would awkwardly pause, and then explain it). My favorite joke with this construction is “A priest, a rabbi, and the President walk into a bar and the bartender says “What is this, a joke?” (And of course the three people could be anybody, as long as they were diverse, and in that joke setup mode.)