Activity
Mon
Wed
Fri
Sun
Dec
Jan
Feb
Mar
Apr
May
Jun
Jul
Aug
Sep
Oct
Nov
What is this?
Less
More
65 contributions to Rebel Economist (Free)
Commodity and non-commodity State money - not so dissimilar?
I give grateful thanks to @Jon Underwood for a Skool conversation that triggered this train of thought. See - https://www.skool.com/stevekeen-free/garbage-from-the-uk-house-of-commons-library?p=f7f23363 Thinking about World X (X for exogenous money), when money was gold, has been useful because it exposed what happened in those bygone days, at the ‘moment of birth’ of old-fashioned commodity money. I hadn't realised that a declaration by the State must be made to create any kind of State money. In my example in the conversation, State-owned gold entered the Treasury as a physical asset. Now I can add a description of commodity money coming into existence by formal declaration - “Hear ye, hear ye. This physical asset is hereby transformed into a monetary asset. There has been a loss of physical assets, reducing the physical equity of the State. There has been a gain in monetary assets, increasing the monetary equity of the State. Let the State’s Accounts show that Transformation. Increase the Asset and Equity entries in those Accounts accordingly. Long live the State”. Two accounting entries were made when commodity money was born. Neither of them was a liability. Of course, that’s an unusual situation in the normal run of accounting when assets and liabilities occur in matched pairs. Something unusual did happen - commodity money was declared into being through transformation of physical into monetary equity. The additional X-world money was nobody’s liability - it wasn’t a debt of the State to anyone. But hang on - States throughout history have surely borrowed gold, especially in times of crisis. But it seems that what they borrowed was the stuff of gold as a physical asset. They didn't borrow accounting entries because those were private money. Prior to the start of the Bank of England, private bank money did not pass as State money. Privare accounting entries could no doubt be borrowed but they could not be merged with State money accounts since the two monies had different status.
0 likes • 20h
@Alwyn Lewis @Gerard Borg “Government spending beyond tax (adding equity to the economy) is financed by a reductiion in government equity - which is Steve's 'overall-seesaw'. “ Yes! Wynne Godley’s Sectoral balances equation. “No debt can be involved since the government, as composite agent, acts alone. “ Gov liabilities/debt are public assets. Not sure what you meant here. “The money created is new, not existing money borrowed.” According to the BoE online database, not factually correct since 2008, “I feel the macro/composite view is the more revealing of the situation in toto.” Yes, it’s the most revealing as it shows how the U.S. is $40T in debt. However, I’d like you both to clearly see, there are two distinct possibilities here’re: new money under model 1 v model 2. Model 1spends first, and deficits arise when tax revenues and fees end up being less than was spent, that means forensically, deficit spending is financed by printing or issuing new money, which has already happened and been spent before it is determined a deficit exists. Under model 2, reserves are around $3T now, they were higher last year, but we had a $2T deficit. Why didn’t reserves go up by $2T? The reason is Treasury borrowed existing money from the public by selling bonds through Equity neutral BS expansion. Selling bonds has no change to Equity. Deficit spending results in negative Equity. Interestingly, the bond buyer completes an asset swap, no change in Equity, so the bonds are not the source of the public’s increase in Equity. MIT’s the new deposits the public receives that they would not have if the Governmdnt did not deficit spend. +Deposits = +Equity, the public receives from the Asset payments Tressury completes. So a transfer of Equity under the sectoral balances equation does not require new money to be created, but it does require a transfer of financial asssts, which is completed through assst payments that show up a new deposits.
0 likes • 16h
@Gerard Borg @Alwyn Lewis Also, this ravel is worth scrutinizing: “However from the common Ravel model https://www.patreon.com/ProfSteveKeen/posts/why-is-steve-not-107942051 I have covered it prior with Gerard. If you look at page 6, (page 7), under the Central Bank ravel, it shows: +L (+Spend/G) -E (-Spend/G) That ‘incomplete model’ as Steve writes is showing model 1 plain and simple: + L = -E Note the Treasury BS has no entries, so this shows no Treasury spending. What then is happening? This is when CB issues money to pay Gov bills. But as he says, it’s incomplete, so we move to the complete version that includes Treasury on the next page. Figure 7 (page8) per Steve “confirm the core MMT insight that the government deficit IS the private sector surplus.” This was what @Alwyn Lewis was referencing, and I showed that this is true under BOTH model 1 and model 2, but Model 1 achieves this by issuing new money when Treasury spends: +L = -E Gov spending = private sector surplus And model 2 achieves this NOT by issuing new net money like Model 1, but by completing an Asset payment, transferring reserves that Treasury borrowed through bond sales back to banks: -A (-R Treasury) = -E Treasury +A (+R Banks) = +E Banks If we look at what Steve is modeling, he shows CB completing a Liability Swap, debiting Treasury and crediting banks with no change to Cb Equity: -Liabilities (-R Treasury) +Liabilities (+R Banks) This by definition is not a net increase in total CB Liabilities or net new reserve account credits, so is not new reserve account credit creation and not fiat money expansion. This is model 2 If you look at Treasury, he has an Asset payment as above: -A ;-R Treasury) = -E Treasury. Again, -E happens under both models, but under model 1 it happens by issuing new money for a Liability payment: +L = -E
FJG vs UBI for full employment and price stability
Preliminary simulations using MESSSI (Macro Economic System State Simulator) developed by Tyron Keynes reveals that whereas the FJG is superior to UBI in targeting this dual objective, nevertheless a combination of the two when applied to lower income earners contributes significantly in reducing overall income and wealth inequalities. https://www.relearningeconomics.com/what-the-messsi-model-says-about-a-ubi-and-fjg
0 likes • Sep 9
@Richard Corin “Settlement accounts do not hold money! You cannot buy dinner with reserves! Reserves are a behind the scenes accounting mechanism and cannot be part of the money supply.” Agree! But those are reserves,, reserve account credits, and Ressrves are nothing more than this. “The money, whether it be government originated fiat money” Reserves + bills that are purchased by banks from the CB by swapping for Reserves, which banks purchased swapping their assets with the CB. All fist is Central bank Ledger credits, nothing more. “ultimately backed by treasury liabilities, “ No! Reserves are not necessarily backed by Treasury bonds, but they can be. The CB only accepts High Quality Liquid Assets HQLA to swap for reserves. “or bank credit money ultimately backed by private liabilities, “ Backed by bank Assets. Deposits are bank liabilities, ledger credits fir customers, backed by the bank’s asset portfolio. “it is only money if it can be used for transactions in the real economy, as opposed to moving assets around the back office accounting mechanism.” If you want to say only bank liabilities are money, fine, they are 97% of the public money supply, with paper bills making up the rest. Therefore, when a government taxes, money is destroyed, -deposits, reserve account credits are moved from one account to another, not de-issued and not destroyed. The only way they can be destroyed is if they are used to pay an CB. and when a government spends, money is created. The money they received from banks, reserve account credits, are spent, meaning returned to banks. The banks then create new IOUs for their customers, new deposits, which they owe but the gov does not. It is wrong to say, "no new money is created", Wrong? Let’s be specific, ‘net’ new money, a net increase in the money supply. Gov spending always results in new deposits, but if those deposits were taxes, then is -Deposits +Deposits = 0 new money? An increase in the money supply?
0 likes • 3d
@James Clark I appreciate your sentiments and the struggle with the financialization of land. Economically, land has no value. When I earned my green MBA, this was a huge trigger for fellow environmentalists, but if it’s not being used to generate GDP, it only has negative value due to taxes, and of course ‘pitetntial’ value if a different owner invested money to make it productive. The first problem with land is distribution. At one point the Crown of England owned or controlled 2/3 of the earth, and it was handed out to the privileged class. Real Estate makes the most millionaires because everyone needs a home, and as population frowns that demand increases, and as incomes rise the demand for more expensive homes also rises. If you consider the financial system is the monetization of assets, you need asssts to access money. However, we have improved that with capitalizing past, present and future productivity, you can sign your name and create an IOU under contract law, and a bank will give you money against your signature, as you provided them an asset, a future payment stream and they provided the net present value of that payment stream, what we call loan principal. When we buy homes the product banks are financing is not the home, that’s the security. Banks are financing the mortgage, which is a way I’d saying they have found a huge container where they can make an enormous amount of money to safely invest. The result? New money drives home prices up, so the more we make the more we grant to lenders and the financial economy. The real economy makes $600b in new growth, but taxpayers pay twice that in interest payments, let alone all those mortgages. To be clear, Fed reserve account credits or reserves are Asset banked 1:1, and so are bank loans, so they are not really ‘created out of thin air,’ because the seller expects to be paid, and banks use their ins assets to pay fir the home while the buyer repays the lender for 30 years.
Garbage from the UK House Of Commons Library
A friend just sent me a link to the 'truth about governmement debt' (hee hee). It's a document from the House of Commons Library https://share.google/eb6g6WlBjESH62ZRE Quoting - "Most borrowing takes place through government bonds called gilts . When investors buy a gilt, they lend money to the government for a fixed period.". Oops - as Steve's accountig shows that's garbage since no money changes hands when Treasury bonds are issued.
0 likes • 18d
@Kevin Carney “Others insist they are franchisees of the Federal Reserve and the Federal Reserve is not public” Public = meaning Government owned? Or public meaning non-Government privately owned? It sounds like your argument here is public = government. I understand the arguments for and against the Fed being publicly owned ur Gov, and some of my friends like to say ‘quasi-governmental’ …I stay clear of that argument for now. This is another ongoing issue of the language around money, similar to the multiple meanings of the word ‘Reserves.’
0 likes • 16d
@Alwyn Lewis “Re. banks, I tend to see 'reserves' as the bank's founding deposit at the CB.” @Kevin Carney and I have discussed this prior, we all use this word reserve or reserves in banking, which has multiple meanings and thus creates enormous confusion. Yes, you are absolutely right Reserves are swapped for bank assets as founding capital. This is important because this is all reserves are, credit entries in a bank’s account on the Federal reserve’s ledger (or CB ledger), which as an institution has assets it holds against these credits. Same as bank’s crediting deposit accounts. But, the CB had no assets of its own from the Gov, no founding capital other than the assets banks contributed or deposited with it, same for Bank of England, so every Fed asset is acquired by issuing new Liabilities, or settlement balances, these reserve account credits, which are called ‘Reserves.’ This is reserves as CB Liabilities, and also bank Assets. That says, banks hold Assets in excess of their Liabilities, just as the CB does, which is excess capital, owner’s equity and in an annual basis profits. These profits or excess assets are hold ‘on reserve’ in case they are needed to fund bank liabilities. That’s not a monetary unit, that’s a measure of excess assets being held on reserve. A bank’s tier one capital ratio or CAR/capital adequacy ratio is defined by excess assets held on reserve, which can be multiple types of assets, not only reserve account credits themselves, so this is a different meaning. “So reserves in that sense are its own money, used to provide a buffer of bank-equity held in reserve against a loss of bank-equity due to borrower-default.” Yes! “I prefer the term 'settlement-balance' (which Canadians seem to use) for the bank assets that balance the bank's 'customer-deposit' book.” These same assets held at the CB are account credits and reserve account credits, true settlement balances. But assets held in reserve are not settlement balances, even though they can be liquidated to settle outstanding balances!
Nyt article
https://www.nytimes.com/2026/10/23/business/economy-2008-financial-crisis.html?smid=nytcore-ios-share Not sure everyone will be able to access the link. Including for those who can. This New York Times article talks about the possibility that the AI investment cycle is going to turn down (implode) and it could cause global financial problems. It sounds an awful lot like Steve’s point that private credit/debt is part of the money supply and removing a lot of money from the economy can cause a recession or a crisis. Of course, the article doesn’t talk about the mechanism. It talks in terms of probabilities, looking at past events. But still, it’s refreshing to see mainstream media with some notion of bubbles and recession tied to bursting of bubbles. In this case, a private debt bubble. If in fact the AI bubble does burst catastrophically, it seems like it could be a good example for Steve to use in making his case. Especially good if the crisis could be predicted based on his analysis.
0 likes • 25d
I see that AI infrastructure is being financed on the balance sheets of tech companies, who are promising long term rents from their vibrant significant revenue streams, and they can absorb these costs. Oracle is the exception, and they likely have to restructure in chapter 7 if there is a crash, but it seems like banks have learned and are largely insulated. This matters because banks create money when they lend, but AI is aggregating existing capital. Banks should be fine, but there may be a liquidity crises, and the mood at central banks currently would be to let it play out rather than intervene. Steve points out in a credit crises the shortest distance to normalcy, and the one that reduces both the magnitude and duration of the disturb, if for the Gov to deficit spend and inject more spending power into the economy. That’s going to be a big lift. Therefore, an AI crash will likely cause pain, but It’s unlikely they crash the banks directly. The indirect threat is Commercial Real Estate crashing, which regional banks exposed to many overpriced zombie loans in empty or under utilized buildings, and pulling the banks down with them. So we’re not insulated, but an AI crash should not immediately and directly threaten the banking system.
AMOC Explanation
I came across this quite simple but still information filled explanation of the AMOC. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YTteQi-qY9w&list=LL&index=2
1 like • Oct 13
@Oliver Williams Great video, thx! I earned a ‘Green’ MBA, and we took inventory of the oceans. On the positive, we studied how the fisheries would have already been wiped out except countries came together voluntarily to cooperate to save them. On the negative we studied the literature of edification if the oceans, which was stunning because they hold 100x more carbon dioxide than anywhere else, and this gets released as the oceans warmed, game over. It was really depressing. We didn’t really understand that in so many systems, Al Gore was saying the decisions that determine the future are right now. That was 20 years ago, and sadly we have long passed the point of no return on many biological ecosystems. The data I have reviewed yes, the ocean currents are going to stop, and life on earth will be fundamentally changed forever because of it.
1-10 of 65
Jon Underwood
4
56 points to level up
@jon-underwood-9465
LinkedIn.com/in/wjunderwood

Active 13h ago
Joined Mar 8, 2025
Powered by