Feb 3 • General 🌐
BREAKING NEWS: Court throws out “zombie second” lawsuit (HELOC)
The takeaway is typically the same: when a borrower gets hit with a foreclosure action including a payoff balance inflated with massive past due interest on a charged-off loan they haven't received a monthly statement on in years... they are legitimately upset (and sometimes fight back).
That's why we advise that you work with homeowners, get win-win deals done and use foreclosure as a last resort.
That being said - a new precedent was set last week: Newrez beats zombie seconds suit over decades-old HELOC debt
What happened:
- A homeowner sued Newrez / Shellpoint and Bank of New York Mellon over a long-dormant second mortgage.
- She said it was unfair to restart collection and add interest after years without monthly statements.
- A federal judge dismissed the case. The court said the borrower used the wrong law to make her argument.
Why the case failed:
- Missing statements are a Truth in Lending (TILA) issue.
- The borrower sued under FDCPA instead.
- Courts say you can’t use FDCPA to enforce TILA rules.
- She also didn’t clearly show who was required to send statements over the years.
Why this matters:
- Servicers can restart old second liens if they follow the rules.
- “Zombie second” cases are not automatic wins for borrowers.
- Courts are focusing on technical legal details, not emotions.
What this means for note investors:
- More old second liens may come back to life.
- Paperwork and servicing history matter more than headlines.
- Bankruptcy history and notice timing are key risks to underwrite.
Bottom line:
Long-dormant seconds are not dead. The law still favors the paper - if it’s handled correctly.
26
15 comments
BREAKING NEWS: Court throws out “zombie second” lawsuit (HELOC)
skool.com/notes
Start (or scale!) your real estate portfolio with Skool's #1 mortgage note investing community.
Leaderboard (30-day)
1
+15
2
+13
3
+13
4
+9
5
+8
Powered by