1d • General discussion
Don't get zapped The perils of free estimates in the insurance shell game
Don't Get Zapped: The Perils of "Free" Estimates and the Insurance Shell Game!
As contractors, we've all been there. We get a call, a homeowner sounds distressed, and we offer a "free estimate" to assess the damage. It's a cornerstone of good customer service, a way to build trust, and frankly, a necessary step to get work. But what happens when that "free estimate" turns into a free consultation for an insurance claim, with you, the contractor, left holding the bag of uncompensated expertise?
The scenario is becoming all too common: Homeowners, savvy to the ways of maximizing their insurance payouts, solicit multiple "free estimates" from contractors. They gather detailed scopes of work, itemized lists, and expert opinions on the extent of the damage – all valuable information that they then hand directly to their insurance adjuster to bolster their claim. Meanwhile, you've spent hours driving to the site, meticulously inspecting, measuring, photographing, and drafting a professional estimate, only to find out the homeowner was never truly serious about hiring you for the job. You've essentially provided a free service to their insurance company, funded by your time, fuel, and expertise.
It's time to put an end to this unspoken exploitation. Contractors need to become proactive, asking critical questions upfront and, more importantly, understanding the immense value of directly engaging with the insurance company when an estimate is for a claim.
The Sneaky "Insurance Job" – How to Spot It (and Stop It)
The moment a homeowner mentions "storm damage," "burst pipe," "fire," or any other incident likely to involve an insurance claim, your antennae should go up. This isn't to say every homeowner is trying to pull a fast one, but you need to protect your business.
The Golden Question: From now on, when a potential client requests an estimate for damage that might be insurance-related, your very first question should be: "Is this job for an insurance claim?"
Their answer will dictate your next steps and can save you countless hours of uncompensated labor.
Why Dealing Directly with the Insurance Company is Non-Negotiable
If the answer to your golden question is "Yes," then it's time to shift gears. This is no longer just a "free estimate" situation. This is a potential partnership with an insurance carrier, and you need to control the flow of information and, crucially, the flow of money.
- Protecting Your Time and Expertise (and Getting Paid for It!): Your Estimate is a Professional Service: Creating a detailed, accurate estimate for insurance purposes is not a trivial task. It requires knowledge of construction, local building codes, material costs, and often specialized software. This is a service you provide. Avoid Being an Unpaid Consultant: When you hand your estimate directly to the homeowner for an insurance claim, you risk becoming an unpaid consultant for their claim. The insurance company then uses your professional assessment to determine their payout, often without ever directly compensating you for your work. Mitigate "Shopping Around" Abuse: By dealing directly with the insurer, you reduce the chances of your estimate being used by the homeowner to haggle with other contractors or simply to secure the highest possible payout without ever intending to hire you.
- Streamlined Payment Coordination (No More Chasing Checks!): Direct-to-Contractor Payment: Many insurance companies prefer, or can be persuaded, to pay contractors directly. This cuts out the homeowner as a middleman, reducing payment delays, disputes, and the risk of the funds being diverted elsewhere. Clearer Scope of Work: When you work directly with the adjuster, you can clarify the agreed-upon scope of work, ensuring that what you're paid to do aligns precisely with what's covered by the policy. This minimizes change orders and misunderstandings down the line. Less Financial Stress: Knowing that the payment is coming directly from the insurance carrier provides a much greater sense of security and significantly improves your cash flow management. No more frantic calls to homeowners wondering where the insurance check went!
- Establishing Professionalism and Credibility: You're the Expert: By taking charge of the insurance process, you position yourself as a knowledgeable and experienced professional who understands the nuances of insurance claims. This builds immense trust with both the homeowner and the insurance company. Advocacy for the Homeowner (and Yourself): You can better advocate for the homeowner's best interests by ensuring the insurance company fully covers all necessary repairs, not just the bare minimum. In doing so, you're also ensuring your business is fairly compensated for a comprehensive job. Building Relationships with Adjusters: Developing good relationships with local insurance adjusters can lead to future referrals and a smoother process on subsequent jobs.
Implementing the "Direct with Insurance" Protocol:
- Educate Your Clients: Explain to homeowners why you prefer to work directly with their insurance company for claims. Frame it as a benefit to them – "It makes the process smoother for you, and we can ensure all necessary repairs are covered directly with your adjuster."
- Get Authorization: Obtain written authorization from the homeowner to communicate directly with their insurance company and share your estimate.
- Initial Contact with the Adjuster: As soon as you have authorization, contact the homeowner's insurance adjuster. Introduce yourself, explain you've assessed the damage, and offer to send your detailed estimate directly to them.
- Send Your Estimate (and Discuss it!): Send your professional estimate to the adjuster. Be prepared to discuss your findings, justify your costs, and negotiate if necessary. Remember, they are trying to pay out the least, and you are trying to ensure the home is fully restored and you are fairly compensated.
- Coordinate Payment: Clearly establish the payment process with the adjuster. Push for direct payment to your company upon completion of the work or in agreed-upon stages.
The Bottom Line: Value Your Expertise!
Your time, skill, and knowledge are valuable assets. Offering truly "free estimates" for complex insurance claims is akin to giving away your product before the sale. By proactively asking if a job is for an insurance claim and then taking the reins to work directly with the insurance company for payment coordination, you protect your business, streamline the process, and ensure you are fairly compensated for every drop of your hard-earned expertise. Don't get zapped by the "free estimate" trap – take control and make sure your business thrives!
This is just something that I've ran into over the years and it seems to be happening a lot more here recently We are in the south and seems like it happens last year than it does up north I've been in both areas but hopefully this will help you to keep things in mind to make sure everything rolls as smooth as it possibly can because one monkey wrench in the plan can completely demolish a well set out or thought out plan. Thanks Nathan P Mr Fixit
0
0 comments
Don't get zapped The perils of free estimates in the insurance shell game
