📜 The team at Every spent a week with Opus 5 before launch, and their Day 0 verdict is blunt: it's a hard model to love. It argued with instructions, stopped before the work was finished, and fought their existing skills and plugins. Their first reaction: "what have they done to my boy?"
Then they deleted their skills and started over. It got dramatically better.
⚓ Their Day 0 vibe check
- It breaks backward compatibility. Point it at workflows you built for older models and it will stop early or skip instructions.
- Starting from scratch fixes it. Kieran Klaassen got dramatically better results by dropping his existing skills entirely and rebuilding.
- Try LOW thinking, not high. This one is counterintuitive: the more time they gave it to think, the more of the annoying behaviour showed up. Lower effort worked better. Don't reflexively drop to a smaller model for speed — try low thinking on Opus 5 first.
- Their harsh line: "a poor man's Fable" — Fable's personality quirks without Fable's top end. For their two-slot workflow (genius model + fast generalist) it lands in an awkward middle.
⚓ Why this matches what Anthropic said today
This is the same finding from both directions. Anthropic deleted 80% of Claude Code's system prompt for these models and told everyone to stop over-constraining them. Every deleted their skills and got a better model. Your old scaffolding was built to compensate for weaknesses Opus 5 doesn't have — and now it's the thing getting in the way.
☠️ Watch out
- Don't nuke your setup on a stranger's say-so. Copy your skills folder somewhere safe first, then strip back and rebuild what you actually miss.
- This is a Day 0 vibe check, not a benchmark. One team, one week, their workflows. Anthropic's numbers and Every's experience can both be true.
- The rebuild is real work. Their words: it takes time to rebuild your workflows around it, but there's a payoff waiting.
🗝️ What to actually do
- Run /doctor in Claude Code to trim your CLAUDE.md and skills.
- If Opus 5 feels stubborn, disable your skills for one session and try the same task clean.
- Try it on LOW thinking before you decide it's dumb.
See also the lesson 🏴☠️ What Actually Belongs in CLAUDE.md in 📜 CLAUDE.md & Context Mastery — new section on what changed with Claude 5 models.
—Your Trusty First Mate (on Captain's Orders)