Proud Cis’ Plea for George Plantagenet’s Life
February, 1478
Palace of Westminister
In April, 1477, George, Duke of Clarence, the brother of King Edward IV, sent eighty armed men from Warwick Castle to fetch Ankarette Twynyho at her home in Somerset. Ankarette was a former lady’s maid to, Isabel Neville, George’s late wife. While it is likely Isabel had died of childbed fever, George accused poor Ankarette of poisoning his Isabel with a toxic cup of ale. Paranoid grief necessitates retribution. Isabel’s maid was his misbegotten revenge for Isabel’s death, natural though it probably was. Ankarette was taken ninety miles to Warwick in three days, a speedy journey on horseback. George set her before a jury he bought and paid for. Ankarette was hanged alongside a man accused of the same invented crime. It was murder wearing the borrowed robes of the law. George did not seem to care.
When King Edward IV heard of his brother's latest act of defiance against the crown, he was at turns, angry, frustrated and grieved. It was the third incident where George committed treason against the Crown of England. Edward, who had definitively won England at the Battle of Tewkesbury in 1471, could no longer excuse a traitor. Edward had George, his own brother, arrested.
By January 1478, Parliament heard the case brought by the king himself. The charges of treason were vast, echoing with a decade of swallowed grievances, rebellions, and betrayals. No one else dared prosecute a royal duke, so Edward bore the terrible weight of it himself. The court condemned George to death after finding him guilty of his crimes. All that remained was the stroke of a quill.
Cecily Neville, Duchess of York, did not wait to be summoned to the privy chamber to discuss George’s fate. “Proud Cis,” they called her—a woman with the blood of kings in her veins, a matriarch who had given life to George and Edward, then shaped and disciplined them to adulthood and beyond. At sixty-two, she possessed a spine of absolute steel. But as she stood outside her son’s privy chamber in the freezing dark of the morning, she was only a mother facing the unthinkable: one of her children was about to allow the slaughter of another.
She thrust the heavy oak door open, ignoring the startled guards. It was a mother’s privilege, even with a sovereign. Inside, the chamber was thick with the smell of beeswax and wood-smoke. Edward sat slumped behind a heavy table. Before him lay a solitary piece of parchment. Standing immediately behind him, a pale ghost in the gloom, was Elizabeth Woodville. The queen’s hand rested on Edward’s velvet-clad shoulder—a delicate, proprietary touch that anchored him to her will.
“George will never stop, Edward,” Elizabeth murmured, her voice as smooth as glass and just as sharp with her destructive intent.
“He declared our children bastards. He allied with Warwick to murder my father. If you leave him breathing, you leave our sons to the wolves.”
Elizabeth stopped as Cecily stepped into the candlelight. The two women locked eyes. The air in the room grew instantly suffocating. Elizabeth offered a shallow, glacial dip of her head before slipping her hand from her husband’s shoulder. She had planted her seed; she knew when to leave the harvest to the king. Without a word to her mother-in-law, the queen swept from the room.
Cecily crossed the floor. She did not kneel. She reached out and placed her hand flat over the blank space at the bottom of the death warrant.
“You look hollowed out,” Cecily said. It was not a royal address; it was the sharp, observing tone of the mother who had raised him. “Have you even slept? Have you eaten?”
Edward let out a breath that sounded like a dry heave. “I did not ask you here to nurse me, Mother. I am well past the cradle.”
“Then do not act like a child breaking his toys because he does not know how to fix them,” she snapped, her pride flaring. “He is your brother. He is of the House of York. We do not spill our own blood.”
“My brother,” Edward said with sarcasm and hurt. “Spilled blood first. Is it my fault George begrudges me my birthright? Nay. Tis not." Standing he towered over his petite mother. With her looking at him in her maternal disapproval, he defended the warrant for George's death.
“I have forgiven him since the rebellion. Since he fled to France. Since he allied with Margaret of Anjou. I forgave him many times. This cannot go on. I am not signing a stranger’s warrant, Mother. I am signing a traitor's, my brother’s, and the ink has been waiting for a decade.”
“If you sign this,” Cecily said, her voice dropping to a fierce whisper, “it will haunt you to the grave. I know you, Edward. A king’s crown offers no refuge from his own conscience. You will grieve him every day you have left.”
“I have grieved George since the day he first turned his sword on me,” Edward replied, his voice breaking. He sank back into his chair, rubbing his eyes.
“I must do this. The queen is right. If I let this pass, I leave my own sons at the mercy of a traitor the moment I am in the ground. A king cannot forgive treason a third time and still wear a crown.”
Cecily looked at her eldest surviving son. She saw the immovable grief in his jaw. At the same time, she recognized the shadow of Elizabeth’s survival instinct covering the parchment. Proud Cis, the fierce, demanding matriarch, shattered in an instant, leaving only a desperate mother who could no longer deny the truth of George’s treachery.
Cecily pulled her hand back from the warrant, moving to enfold her son’s, her eyes locked on his brown ones with a desperate plea.
“Then let it not be the block,” she whispered, her voice fracturing. “Not the drawing, the hanging, the horrors reserved for common traitors. The crowds will cheer as they butcher your brother. Do not let them have his dignity, Edward. Let it be private. Grant me this much mercy, if further kindness proves impossible.
Edward stared at her. The silence stretched until it felt like a physical weight. Slowly, the king reached out and covered his mother’s trembling hand with his own. Something profound and wretched passed between them, a surrender.
There were no crowds when the Tower executed George eleven days later. There was no public butchery. Legend claims that George drowned in a butt of expensive wine called Malmsey. In truth, people are uncertain how they executed him because they secluded him in his last moments. Like the Princes in the Tower, this secret is possibly one we will never hear the truth of.
Cecily was a mother first, though she carried herself as a queen, according to sources I have read. She was the granddaughter of John of Gaunt by his mistress, and later wife, Katherine Swynford. An indomitable woman to her children, Cecily, the mother of kings, walked into the King’s chamber knowing Elizabeth Woodville had already sealed George’s fate. She fought the battle to save her son, anyway. One grace, a private dispatch from this earth was granted. Edward and Margaret Plantagenet, George’s children, would not be so fortunate when the Tudors took their lives. That is a story for another day.
Question for you.
What moves me most about this historical moment is the pivot Cecily makes. She walks in as “Proud Cis,” demanding a royal pardon, but has the devastating clarity to realize when she must stop playing the Duchess and start pleading as a mother. She couldn’t save her son’s life, so she stayed in the room long enough to save his dignity.
If you’ve read much about Cecily Neville or the Wars of the Roses, I’d love to know: Does a mother’s fierce, unconditional instinct to protect a guilty son read as strength to you, or does it complicate your view of her? Reply and tell me where you land.
Until the next candle,
Christy