"Controlling" - he wouldn't let you be a 304. "Verbally Abusive" - he voiced and enforced accountability and his standards. "Emotionally Unavailable" - he wouldn't argue with her to satisfy her emotional stimulation needs. If you do decide to stimulate, make sure you're always the cause (you're consciouly triggering her) and never the effect (she's triggering you). "We Grew Aprart" - her single friends more than likely convinced her to want to be single. Birds of a feather, flock together. There will always be exceptions, but the exceptions cannot disprove the rule.