@Oscar Paez A civilization’s foundational values are defined by the philosophical, moral, and political traditions upon which it was built—not by every ideology that happens to emerge within its borders; otherwise, you would have to argue that every movement arising within a civilization is equally representative of its fundamental principles. Clearly, the fact that the KKK, Nazism and communism arose in Western societies does not mean they embodied Western civilization’s foundational values; their suppression of individual liberty, human rights, and the rule of law directly contradicted those values. From Magna Carta and the Enlightenment to the Declaration of Independence, Western civilization developed a profound tradition of individual liberty, equality before the law, and inherent human rights. It was by appealing to these very principles that abolitionists challenged slavery, Britain abolished the slave trade, Americans fought a Civil War that ended slavery, and the civil rights movement dismantled Jim Crow. These struggles demonstrate that a civilization's foundational ideals should not be confused with its historical failures to uphold them; indeed, those ideals often provided the moral foundation for correcting those very injustices. "White people?" "Like me?" My comment about El-Sayad was not based on group identity, but his character - his beliefs and values as demonstrated through in his own words and actions. Once again, you really should mature beyond your progressive, ideological worldview.